A screencast!
So, aaron screencasted last week, and talked about the Plasma kpart from a general point of view… Let’s take a gander at my bug-ridden code which uses said kpart to make a plasma dashboard in Kontact! 🙂
=-=-=-=-=
Powered by Blogilo
So, aaron screencasted last week, and talked about the Plasma kpart from a general point of view… Let’s take a gander at my bug-ridden code which uses said kpart to make a plasma dashboard in Kontact! 🙂
=-=-=-=-=
Powered by Blogilo
Sorry but I am afraid I don’t really get why the overview should use plasma. Imo the current view is a lot more clean, consistend and provides me all the info I need with a glimpse of the eye and without the need to scroll or whatever. So why change something when it is not broken and when the new way — as it appears to me — does not really offer much more?
Take the fonts e.g., in the current view you have like two different font sizes, while you have multiple here. Also you have one background for everything now and would have multiple for every applet then.
Imo Plasma is a nice technology, but it does not need to be everywhere just for the sake of it.
mat69 said this on 1 October 2010 at 14:08 |
So, I was writing a reply to your comment, when Aaron more or less did the same thing on his blog. Since my thoughts more or less mirror him, and he’s far more eloquent, I’ll just copypasta it:
http://aseigo.blogspot.com/2010/10/on-impending-future-of-ui-greatnesses.html
Ryan Rix said this on 1 October 2010 at 20:31 |
Sorry if I missed it from the Aaron’s blog post, but it does not address the styling / inconsistent issues the mat69 also mentioned.
Would it be possible to create a plasma theme that would mimic the normal app elements and style, to be used when plasmoids are being included within the apps? Because also I find the plasmoids being out-of-place when embedded in the apps.
Anyway, glad to see Kontact summary getting some love – and I’m sure you already have plans to add that elegance as well 🙂
jmu said this on 1 October 2010 at 23:54 |
That doesn’t really convince me either, in some cases a monolithic approach is imo better than exporting everything in everywhere available plugins (you could say that plasmoids are that to a degree).
With the monolithic approach you can polish something exactly to its usecases while in the other case something like that is either not possible or hard to achieve –> to satisfy all the use-cases a good looking, consistent and useable way.
Take plasma applets, their look depends to a large degree on the theme used, so it can happen that they could look out of place, unless a fixed style is used in the Kontact case. And further that style also defines the place the applets will use — by default fonts etc. — so to have a consistent experience in a program that still is mostly QWidget based one would have to work around one of the features of Plasma.
It starts with the formfactor, in general QWidgets have the same font-size, no matter if they are resized or not. That does not hold true for plasma applets, resize the calendar to something larger and you get larger fonts, vice versa. That might be ok on the desktop but looks imo out of place in an application.
Yes and as mentioned I understand that the applets can be fine tuned, but imo that is a maintenance problem –> who will do that? It is a lot harder to fine tune a lot of apps that work differently internally than to maintenace a small set of hardly changing tools.
I really hope that all of my concerns will be non-founded, though I fear that the experience won’t be as polished and straight foward anymore.
mat69 said this on 2 October 2010 at 01:51 |
It is true that this dashboard needs MUCH love. Because, currently user-wise it is worse than the current summary view in Kontact.
And the topic with Plasma themes is quite a problem now – although in theming Plasma is quite diverse, finding a good Plasma theme is still quite hard – most of them are of quite low quality and need much love. And I truly do not want to have in my contact the theme from my desktop.
Maybe this tendence with “Everything is applett” is targeted at using these appletts in the future on all kind of hand-helds?
andrez said this on 2 October 2010 at 02:15 |
Answered that on aseigo’s blog — blogs really suck for discussion, meh:
Well I was the one with the first comment on the new Kontact summary page.
Who is going to provide a consistent look? Who will work on that?
The thing I fear is that “(a) improved what is already there” will not happen, the main priority — provide a lot of information in a easy graspable, consistent (with the rest of the program) way as fast as possible — seems to degrade.
In any case I hope that the discussion will remain there and not be here, so I’ll also post that post there.
mat69 said this on 2 October 2010 at 03:27 |